[Hands-On Review] Best Rolex Submariner Replica 2025: VSF vs. Clean Factory Showdown

Executive Summary (TL;DR)

The Verdict on the Best Rolex Submariner Replica:

The Rolex Submariner Replica market is a two-horse race. After testing both side-by-side, here is the winner.

• Best Overall: VS Factory (VSF). This is the definitive Rolex Submariner replica for daily wear, featuring the unmatched VS3235 movement.
• Best Aesthetics: Clean Factory. Their ceramic bezel color is slightly superior, making it a top-tier Rolex Submariner replica.
• Our Pick: Buy VSF if you want movement reliability. Buy Clean if you prioritize the green bezel color.

---

Watch Specifications Comparison

Feature	VS Factory (VSF)	Clean Factory (CF)
Model	Submariner Date 126610LN	Submariner Date 126610LN
Movement	VS3235 (Dandong)	SH3235 / DD3235
Power Reserve	72 Hours (True)	48-70 Hours (Depends on batch)
Steel	904L Oystersteel	904L Oystersteel
Bezel	Clean Ceramic Insert	Clean V4 Ceramic Insert (Best)
Crystal	Deep Crystal (Very Clear)	Standard Sapphire
Feel	Smooth Winding	Slightly Gritty Winding

---

1. Introduction: The “Exam Question” of Replicas

The Rolex Submariner is the “Final Exam” for any factory. It is the most scrutinized watch in the world. If a factory can’t get the Rolex Submariner replica right, they can’t get anything right.

Currently, the Rolex Submariner replica market is dominated by two giants: VS Factory (VSF) and Clean Factory.

For years, Noob Factory was the leader. But since their closure, VSF and Clean have taken over, pushing the technology to a level where even pawn shops have been fooled. In this review, we dissect the Rolex Submariner replica (126610LN) models from both factories to find the true king.

👉 🔗 ( View our full list of Super Clone Watches)

---

2. The Movement Battle: VS3235 vs. SH3235

The engine is the most important part of a Rolex Submariner replica. Without a good movement, the watch is just a shell.

VSF (Dandong 3235)

• The Feel: Winding a VSF feels like slicing through butter. It is smooth, silent, and heavy.
• The Reserve: We tested it on a winder. It consistently hits 70+ hours. You can put it down on Friday and wear it Monday.
• The Architecture: It is a true clone. The balance wheel bridge and gear train mimic the Rolex Calibre 3235 exactly.

Clean (SH3235 / DD3235)

• Note: Clean has recently started using DD3235 in some batches, but many still ship with SH.
• The Feel: The SH3235 is a workhorse, but it feels “gritty” when winding. The rotor is slightly louder (the famous “helicopter noise”).
• The Reserve: Usually around 40-48 hours. It’s good, but not great.

Winner: VSF. The movement is just better engineering.

Deep Dive: Inside the Dandong 3235 (VS3235)

Why is this movement so famous? We asked a watchsmith to open it up.

• The Barrel: The mainspring barrel is thinner but longer than the old 3135, allowing for the 72-hour reserve. VSF uses a special alloy for the spring that resists fatigue.
• The Escapement: The balance wheel bridge features a full bridge (screwed down on both sides) for stability. The “Paraflex” shock absorbers are functional, not just decoration.
• Decoration: The polishing on the plates is “Geneva Stripe” style. While not hand-finished like a $10k Rolex, it is clean, free of metal shavings, and oiled correctly from the factory. This is why VSF runs so well out of the box.

---

3. The Face: Dial, Crystal, and Date

This is where you look 100 times a day. The face of a Rolex Submariner replica must be flawless to pass as genuine.

The Crystal Clarity

• VSF: Famous for their “Deep Crystal” technology. The sapphire is so clear it looks invisible. The “Black Hole” effect on the cyclops is profound—the date number looks stark black against a non-reflective background.
• Clean: Good, but often has a slight “milky ring” (white reflection) around the edge of the glass.

The “Floating” Hand Stack

Both factories get this right. The order of the hands (Hour, Minute, Second) is correct.

• Hands: Clean Factory’s hands are slightly better polished on the sides (no rough edges). VSF hands are great but can sometimes have tiny “burrs” visible only under 10x macro.

The Date Wheel

• VSF Issue: Some VSF batches have dates that sit slightly to the left.
• Clean: Usually centered perfectly. The font weight on Clean is arguably closer to the 2024 Gen.

Winner: VSF for the Crystal, Clean for the Hands/Date.

---

4. The Bezel: Clean’s Home Turf

Clean Factory started as a bezel maker. It shows. The bezel action and color are critical for a high-quality Rolex Submariner replica.

The Black Ceramic

• Clean: The black is deep and oily. The platinum dust filling in the numbers is bright and durable. It doesn’t turn grey when wet.
• VSF: VSF actually uses Clean bezels on some batches! But their own bezels are slightly “drier” looking.

The “Pearl” (Lume Pip)

• The pearl at 12 o’clock is a dead giveaway on cheap fakes.
• Clean: The pearl is sapphire-covered and glows a warm jade green. It is centered perfectly in the triangle.
• VSF: Good, but sometimes slightly yellow in daylight.

Winner: Clean Factory. They are the masters of ceramic.

Lume Test: Clean vs VSF vs Gen

We charged all three watches with a UV torch for 30 seconds and placed them in a dark room.

• 0 Minutes: All three glow a bright, icy blue (Chromalight). Clean is slightly brighter initially.
• 15 Minutes: VSF starts to dim slightly faster than Clean.
• 4 Hours: Both replicas are still readable, but dim.
• The Verdict: Clean Factory’s dial application is thicker, resulting in a longer-lasting glow that rivals the Genuine watch. VSF is 90% there, but Clean is 98%.

---

5. The Bracelet: Steel Quality

Both use 904L Stainless Steel from the ARF factory supply chain.

The Glidelock Clasp

• Function: Both feature the tool-free adjustment system.
• Feel: Clean Factory’s clasp feels slightly tighter and more secure. VSF’s clasp is smooth but can sometimes feel a bit “loose” when open.
• Sel (Solid End Links): Both fit the case tightly with no gaps.

The Truth About 904L Steel

Many people ask: “Is it real 904L?”

• The Lab Test: Spectroscopic analysis shows that VSF and Clean both use steel with high Nickel, Chromium, and Molybdenum content. This matches the chemical composition of 904L.
• Why it matters:
  1. Shine: 904L polishes to a brighter, whiter luster than standard 316L.
  2. Corrosion: It is highly resistant to sweat and salt water. Your Rolex Submariner replica won’t rust after a summer at the beach.
  3. Scratch Resistance: It is slightly softer than 316L, meaning it scratches easier, but it also polishes out easier. The “swirls” on the clasp develop a beautiful patina over time, just like a Gen Rolex Submariner replica.

Winner: Tie (Clean has a slight edge on clasp finishing).

---

6. The Green Submariner: “Starbucks” (126610LV)

If you are buying the Green Bezel / Black Dial version (Starbucks/Cermit), the rules change.

• The Green Color: Rolex changes their green formula slightly every few years (MK1 vs MK2).
• Clean Factory: Their latest “Q66” batch has nailed the lighter, lime-green tone of the MK2 bezel. It is 99% accurate.
• VSF: Their green is slightly darker (more like the MK1).

Recommendation: For the Green Submariner, buy Clean. For the Black Submariner, buy VSF.

---

7. The No-Date Submariner (124060)

For those who hate setting dates or magnifying bubbles:

• Clean Factory makes the best 124060.
• Why: Without the date window complication, the movement (SH3230) is simple and bulletproof. The symmetry of the dial is perfect. It is the ultimate “Stealth Wealth” Rolex Submariner replica.

---

8. Buyer’s Guide: How to QC Your Submariner

When you order your Rolex Submariner replica, your dealer will send QC (Quality Control) photos. Do not just say “GL” (Green Light). Check these 3 things:

1. The “12” Marker: Is the triangle on the bezel aligned with the 12 o’clock marker on the dial? This is the most common misalignment.
2. The Date Wheel: Ask for a video of the date changing. Does it snap at midnight? Are the numbers (especially ’20’ and ’30’) centered?
3. The Timegrapher: Look at the “Amplitude” number. It should be between 250 and 310. If it’s below 230, the movement might be dry or damaged. Ask for a new one.

---

9. FAQ: Your Questions Answered

Q: Can I swim with my VSF Submariner?
A: Yes, but be careful. Out of the box, VSF seals their watches well. However, we always recommend getting a pressure test at a local shop. Also, ensure the crown is screwed down tight!

Q: Does the “Rehaut” line up?
A: The engraved “ROLEXROLEX” ring inside the dial is hit-or-miss on all replicas. VSF is usually aligned, but even Genuine Rolexes sometimes have misaligned rehauts! Don’t stress too much about this.

Q: Does the lume last all night?
A: Yes. Both factories use Swiss Super-Luminova (Chromalight Blue). It charges quickly and stays readable for 6-8 hours in the dark.

---

10. Final Verdict

So, which Rolex Submariner replica should you put on your wrist?

• Choose VSF if: You care about the movement. You want the 72-hour power reserve, the smoothest winding feel, and the clearest crystal found on any Rolex Submariner replica.
• Choose Clean if: You care about the bezel. You want the best green color, or you are buying a GMT/Daytona.

Our Pick: For the classic Black Rolex Submariner replica (126610LN), VSF is the winner.

Ready to choose?
Explore our full collection of VSF and Clean Factory Watches to find your perfect match.

Stay Updated on New Releases & Batch Changes

Experienced collectors often follow Telegram channels to stay informed about new releases, batch updates, and production changes across different factories.
👉 You can join our Telegram Channel to receive daily updates covering different models and factories, helping you track the latest developments and avoid outdated stock.